Real Hardwood Decking vs Composite Decking

Written by on

Choosing a decking material for your building project is not a decision you should take lightly. As a long-term investment that you will be enjoying for many years to come, your deck should look great...and be built to last.

Machiche hardwood deck

Whether you're dreaming about a backyard deck or a rooftop recreation area, it’s essential to understand the materials available for your project. Two of the most popular types of decking are composite and real hardwood. Let’s see how they compare, so you can make an informed choice about which material best suits your project.

 

Aesthetics

Real Hardwood

From the handsome dark brown of Ipe decking to the warm luster of Garapa, real hardwoods have a natural beauty that just can’t be replicated. Spectacular graining variations and unique character marks add to the organic aesthetic quality. They can be refinished with an oil sealer occasionally, if you prefer the 'new wood' look. Or hardwood decking can also age gracefully, often taking on mellow tones and a silver patina over the years, for a low maintenance decking option.

 Ipe deck weathered to silvery gray patina naturally

Learn more about "How Exterior Hardwoods Weather" here

 

Composite

Manufactured using a mix of wood fibers and polymers, composite decking has historically had an artificial, plastic-type appearance. Nowadays, modern composites are available that do a better job of resembling wood deck boards. However, the issue of color fade remains – exposure to the sun’s ultra-violet rays can lead to a fast fade, meaning replacement boards stand out like a sore thumb.  Composite decking also has a tendency to 'ugly out' before it actually wears out.

composite decking fading and discoloration

 

Strength

Real Hardwood

Extremely high-density hardwoods, such as Ipe and Machiche, make for an incredibly reliable decking material. Specifically chosen for their exceptional strength, these hardwoods are resistant to all kinds of heavy-duty wear and tear.  No other decking materials are naturally stronger, or can span farther, than high density hardwood decking.

Mataverde_Ipe_decking_selected_for_Rye_Playland_boardwalk-resized-600Ipe decking is exceptionally strong and lasts long, naturally

Composite

While composite decking is designed to reproduce the strength of a natural hardwood, it falls far short. The span rating is very low, and it tends to sag somewhat between the deck joists. There have also been many complaints of weakening and issues of poor-quality control procedures since composite decking appeared on the market. In 2005 and 2009, the U.S. Consumer Products Safety Commission issued recalls on two leading brands of composite decking due to compromised safety.  

composite-deck-flaking-resized-600

 

Durability

Real Hardwood

High quality hardwoods such as Machiche decking, Garapa, Cumaru, Ipe and ThermoWood are extremely resistant to mold, fungal decay and extreme weathering, as well as termites and other insects. They are also impervious to warping, expansion and contraction and often have a usable life expectancy of more than 30 years.

Ipe boardwalk at Nashawannuck Pond

Composite

With a typical usable life expectancy of less than 15 years, composite decking isn’t up to standard when it comes to durability. Mold and water retention problems, a host of complaints involving weakening and a lack of research dedicated into improving future products mean that composite decking, in its current form, just doesn’t last as well as hardwoods.

composite_decking_deteriorating_and_crumbling

 

Sustainability

Real Hardwood

With a low life cycle cost and a usable life expectancy of more than 30 years, real hardwood is the most sustainable decking material available. Hardwoods such as Machiche or Santa Maria (both FSC® Certified decking material options) are ethically harvested, using only what is needed to ensure that the trees regrow, leaving very little negative impact on the environment.

Composite

No natural resources are renewed during the production of composite decking. In fact, it’s made up of various man-made materials – often petroleum byproducts from oil manufacturers. And while composite decking has a usable life expectancy of less than 15 years, the material itself actually lasts a lifetime afterwards– unfortunately, in a landfill.

 

If you'd like to learn more about decking material options, and deciding on the best decking for your project, DOWNLOAD "The Ultimate Guide to Selecting the Right Decking".

download the free ultimate guide to decking

Comments

Related Posts

Back to top